PICK-BY-PICK

// 2024 · Mock vs actual at each slot

HIT = correct player and team at the slot. CLOSE = right player wrong team, right position and team, or player within three slots on the board. MISS = everything else. See methodology for trade and chaos notes.

Pick	Team	Actual	MCSHAY	KIPER	PFF	JEREMIAH	MILLER	BRUGLER	REUTER
1	CHI	Caleb Williams	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT
2	WAS	Jayden Daniels	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT
3	NE	Drake Maye	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT
4	ARI	Marvin Harrison Jr.	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
5	LAC	Joe Alt	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
6	NYG	Malik Nabers	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
7	TEN	JC Latham	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT
8	ATL	Michael Penix Jr.	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	MISS
9	CHI	Rome Odunze	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
10	MIN	JJ McCarthy	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT
11	NYJ	Olu Fashanu	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	CLOSE
12	DEN	Bo Nix	HIT	HIT	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT
13	LV	Brock Bowers	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	MISS	HIT	HIT
14	NO	Taliese Fuaga	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE
15	IND	Laiatu Latu	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	MISS	HIT	HIT
16	SEA	Byron Murphy II	CLOSE	MISS	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE
17	MIN	Dallas Turner	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	MISS
18	CIN	Amarius Mims	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
19	LAR	Jared Verse	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT
20	PIT	Troy Fautanu	CLOSE	HIT	MISS	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT
21	MIA	Chop Robinson	MISS	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	MISS	HIT	MISS
22	PHI	Quinyon Mitchell	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE
23	JAX	Brian Thomas Jr.	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	MISS	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE
24	DET	Terrion Arnold	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
25	GB	Jordan Morgan	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE
26	TB	Graham Barton	CLOSE	MISS	MISS	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	MISS
27	ARI	Darius Robinson	CLOSE	MISS	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
28	KC	Xavier Worthy	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
29	DAL	Tyler Guyton	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT
30	BAL	Nate Wiggins	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	CLOSE	HIT	HIT
31	SF	Ricky Pearsall	CLOSE	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT	HIT
32	CAR	Xavier Legette	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE	HIT	CLOSE